The Fort is Being Redeveloped, But Who's Gonna Pay For All This Anyway?

And what the heck is taking so long?

Before the Fort Monmouth Economic Revitalization Authority (FMERA) can take possession of any Army property at the fort, there are a few federal hoops to jump through.

What's taking so long?

One of those is the Memorandum of Agreement or MOA, a standardized business document that military agencies use, which defines the contractual relationship the military will have with an entity like FMERA. Members of the FMERA board and staff have been working with the Army for months to hash out the details of how and when, and under what conditions, the property that lies in three boroughs can be conveyed.

"The MOA is not required by law," says FMERA spokeperson, Laura Jones, "but is the Army’s preferred path forward."

Right now the MOA is still in draft form. This means it is a work in progress and it also means the public isn't privy to it yet.

Another closely related hoop, is the application for Economic Development Conveyance (EDC), which is required by the federal government before a base (or in this case, a fort) can be turned over. The MOA -- the over-arching agreement between FMERA and the Army -- is the basis for the EDC. 

Part of getting EDC approval is showing that FMERA has a plan of sustainable growth and development for the site, including job creation. One of the ways FMERA intends to do this is with an electronic masterplan designed by the firm, . In April, Matrix presented its preliminary work on a Georaphic Information Systems database which the firm says will be a key tool in marketing the properties in the fort to developers and businesses, with the end goal being job creation and sustainability. An updated version of the electronic masterplan is expected within a month. 

The EDC application, like the MOA is a work in progress. There is no set time line for this, FMERA says.

Who's footing the bill?

According to FMERA, the MOA identifies the split with the Army, but the detailed financials are in the pro forma, which is part of the EDC application. Again, this has not been finalized.

Here's where the conveyance of the property deviates from you selling your house. In the case of selling a residential home, the buyer and seller negotiate a price and the buyer pockets the proceeds, minus a realtor's commission. Here, FMERA has told the Army that because the property is 94 years old -- and many of its buildings and infrastructure decrepit or outdated -- there are costs to taking ownership of the fort that need to be accounted for in conveyance. 

Some of these costs outlined in April, when Matrix presented its initial findings, were:

  • Environmental contamination, which must be remediated (at the Army’s expense).
  • Crumbling infrastructure, such as the electrical system that one Matrix representative referred to as “at the end of its life.”
  • Roadways that don’t meet Department of Transportation standards.
  • Buildings that are so big that they may be difficult to market.
  • Buildings that are not up to codes, some with asbestos and lead paint.
  • 50-year-old pipes that need to be replaced.

"We've been adament about this since December,"  said Bruce Steadman, executive director of FMERA, "and they [the Army] have heard us."

Another difference from you selling your house, is that the fort will be conveyed in stages over a course of years, with parcels being transfered individually. Over time, the 1,100 + acre property will be carved up into many smaller properties.

According to Steadman, FMERA and the Army meet regularly to work out the details of conveyance, part of which is agreeing on a percentage of the proceeds that will be directed back to FMERA, who will in turn dole out the funds to the boroughs involved, and itself, for qualified expenses.

"This," Steadman said,  "makes the Army an equity partner in the sale."

The key is qualifed expenses. BRAC law determines 12 categories of expenses acceptable for FMERA or a borough to claim as a result of taking possession of the fort. An example of those expenses might be a town's increased need for fire or police protection. According to the Association of Defense Communities Web site, a few others acceptable expense include:

  • municipal infrastructure;
  • demolition;
  • historic property preservation;
  • marketing the project.

This, says FMERA, prevents any undue burden that Oceanport, Tinton Falls and Eatontown might feel as their towns swell in acerage.

Money will be set aside, Steadman said, for incremental costs. The money will not just be deposited into a town's general funds, but set aside to defray costs until tax revenues come in from tenants of the buildings sold or leased within the fort.

This process will be complex and involve reviews of the expenses and audits, and expenses will have a limit.

Is anyone doing anything?

For those on the outside of the FMERA bubble it can seem that nothing is happening to ready the fort for transfer, even as the countdown moves past eight weeks. This is mainly because negotiations between FMERA and the Army (and those with potential investors) are private.

Another cause might be that FMERA has its hands in many key projects - marketing, negotiations, environmental auditing, security and fire planning, drafting the MOA, creating real estate guidelines and historical preservation, to name a few. Like a major home renovation, where many projects are going simultaneously, there's not a whole lot to show for the work until the contractor pulls away and the realtor plunks down the For Sale sign.

Steadman said with closure imminent, FMERA is close to nailing down the details with the Army and he is confident that an agreement will be reached by September. Even in the next couple weeks, he expects to have reports on the environmental audits of the fort and a security plan.

"We're getting ready to wrap a nice big bow around it," he said.

Thomas A. Blasi July 26, 2011 at 05:10 PM
The best course of action that can be taken, after September 15th is to shut off the utilities, board up the buildings and lock the gates of Fort Monmouth. It is critical that the residents & taxpayers of Eatontown, Shrewsbury and the other town that abuts the installation begin to look this ‘gift horse’ in the mouth and realize there are no free lunches. The acquisition of this Brobdingnagian monster is tantamount to someone giving you a free GM Hummer, a vehicle no longer manufactured, expensive to operate, environmentally unfriendly and ugly. Let’s consider some of the costs the taxpayers three communities will be saddled with: A crumbling infrastructure, non compliance roadways, building so large that they are not marketable in addition to not being up to code, 50 year old water and sanitary sewerage pipes that need to be replaced and more. (Continued below)
Thomas A. Blasi July 26, 2011 at 05:14 PM
Continued comment from above:Let’s examine this DOD ‘free lunch’ further. A Field House complete with pool! Does anyone want it? Ocean Fitness; like other such facilities has been on the block for years. The Commissary! Supermarkets are closing their doors in record numbers, remember the Pathmark Supermarket on Rt. 36? The Hospital! Considering Monmouth Medical Center, Riverview and several other medical facilities, there is an abundance of bed space! The PX! Do we need really another strip mall; half of the existing strip malls in the surrounding area are empty. The movie theater! I count 9 in the area with multi screens such as the Monmouth Mall. The Bowling Alley! Bowling was once a thriving blue collar pastime, today’s generation X has little interest in Bowling. The sewerage treatment plant once used to neutralize the facial matter of 10,000 federal workers . . . do we really have a need for it now that they are gone? And how about (Continued below)
Thomas A. Blasi July 26, 2011 at 05:15 PM
(Cont'd from above) The Meyer Center; better known as the incomplete hexagonal shaped structure and visible from the Garden State Parkway; it contains more rooms than the Plaza Suite, who would want it? Several Gas Stations on the post too. Have you noticed that gas stations are being boarded up, when was the last time you saw a new gas station being built? How about the golf course! We have an abundance of both public and private courses and, who do you know that plays golf on a regular basis? I understand the emotion and sentiment involved in this issue especially by those who worked at Fort Monmouth or the retired military but, in these times of change and economic uncertainty we must think outside of the box and call in the wrecking ball.
Bob English July 27, 2011 at 12:30 PM
Tom...no doubt there are lots of issues to work through which are being addressed by FMERA. As far as many are concerned though, the number one goal is to replace the 5,000+ jobs that were/are being lost with the closure of the Fort. That is a huge blow to the economy of the area as well as home values. Working on laying and implementing the framework to accomplish that goal to what FMERA is doing. As far as the buildings that are there now and what is there in the future, I think that will be driven to a large degree by potential developers. With that said, some of the other issues you have raised (especially relating to environmental) need to be kept on the front burner.
Sal August 12, 2011 at 07:32 PM
Jobs are only created by Consumer DEMAND for goods and services. Neither additional office or warehouse space creates DEMAND which in turn creates JOBS. Cash strapped Consumers cannot even support the existing businesses or pay their mortgages or taxes on time. LESS will always equal less. Less Federal and State spending, stagnant wages, social security and federal pension freezes, state pension reductions etc. will result in Less jobs and Less Consumer Demand in the years ahead.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »