patching...
Breaking: Belmar's Boardwalk is Open For Summer »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

NJ Lawmakers Slam Feds on Commissary Closure

Times are tight, says the Department of Defense, and the commissary has got to go. FMERA says: "This is a huge disappointment."

 

It's official, finally. At the close of business on Tuesday, Sept. 13, the Fort Monmouth commissary will shutter its doors for good.

Washington got the news first and now New Jersey's lawmakers are throwing down.

In a joint statement released Tuesday, U.S. Senators Frank R. Lautenberg (D-NJ) and Robert Menendez (D-NJ), and Representatives Frank Pallone, Jr. (D-NJ-6) and Rush Holt (D-NJ-12), "slammed the U.S. Department of Defense (DOD) for its decision to close the Fort Monmouth commissary when the base closes next month."

The lawmakers had been hot on the case of the DOD for more than a year trying to get the department to cease or delay closure of the commissary which serves, according to the governor's office, 22,000 area veterans. In June, the governor joined the growing chorus calling on the department to hold off on the closure.

In July, Patch interviewed Holt after he met with members of the House Appropriations Subcommittee on Defense to gain support for a two year extension for the beloved fort store which delivers food and household goods to military personnel and retirees at significant savings.

At that time a representative for the Defense Commissary Agency (DeCA) said that DOD policy would only allow for the store to stay open if there were 100 active duty military using it, a criteria, he said, Fort Monmouth's commissary wouldn't meet.

In February, state lawmakers hailed a small victory when they got the support of Army Secretary John McHugh who reccommended to the DOD that the commissary stay open on a trial basis for an additional two years. 

During the months since this request the DOD remained silent about the secretary's request, which left local officials, veterans and retirees pulling out their hair. In June Freeholder and veterans advocate Lillian Burry said she had it on good authority that the DOD was leaning in the direction of keeping the store open. "We've received a stay of execution," she told the board of the Fort Monmouth Economic Revitalization Authority (FMERA).

That stay turned out to be just six weeks when the closing was moved from Aug. 1 to Sept. 13.

On Wednesday, the DOD finally confirmed that it would not extend the life of the commissary.

"After careful review and analysis, the DOD approved the DeCA oversight Board of Directors recommendation to discontinue commissary and exchange operations at Fort Monmouth, New Jersey," said a DOD spokeswoman.

According to the spokeswoman, when a military installation closes, generally the commissary does too.

"In this constrained budgetary environment," the spokeswoman said, "the department must take advantage of all previously approved and programmed savings, so we can realign resources to better support force structure changes."

Bruce Steadman, director of FMERA, the authority charged with redevelopment of the fort property, was not pleased at the news.

"Clearly we are disappointed that the undersecretary did not take the governor’s recommendation to keep it open for two more years. Army Secretary McHugh had made the same recommendation,"  Steadman told Patch on Wednesday. "This is a huge disappointment for the community, the customers of the commissary, for FMERA and for the rest of the stakeholders.  The governor’s office is planning on appealing to Secretary (of Defense Leon) Panetta, and have requested a copy of the independent review board’s report to the undersecretary.”

The DOD says closing the commissary will save the department an estimated $2.8 million annually. Authorized patrons can still enjoy the commissary benefit by using the commissaries at Lakehurst NAES (30 miles), Joint Base Lakehurst-McGuire-Dix (46 miles) and Fort Hamilton (45 miles).

For those military families in Monmouth County under their own "constrained bugetary environment," and who have counted on the average 25-30 percent discount as part of their budget, this may seem a bitter consolation.

Related Topics: Commissary closing, Fort Monmouth, and Fort Monmouth Commissary

Thomas A. Blasi

11:23 pm on Wednesday, August 10, 2011

Why not give the people who use the commissary vouchers in which they can shop at any supermarket in the area and pay the same amount as they would pay at the commissary? What is so difficult about that?

Reply

vanessa

7:57 am on Thursday, August 11, 2011

There are over 100 active duty that use the commissary. From NWS Earle and Reserve center.

Reply

Eric P

1:14 pm on Thursday, August 11, 2011

As a tax payer, I refuse to subsidize food and household goods for 22,000 non-military civilians. They can pay full price just like the rest of us! This is why the government is drowning in debt, because everyone feels they are entitled to their own slice of government largess. This is despicable.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Lynn D

9:34 pm on Thursday, August 11, 2011

In response to Eric P: The 22,000 area veterans the article talks about are not civilians. They are military retirees and their dependents. Military retirees who spent at least 20 years defending their country. The only thing despicable is the fact that retired military personnel get so little in the way of benefits. A lot of active duty service members choose to retire in communities near military bases because they are entitled to military healthcare and the discounted shopping available at commissaries and exchanges world-wide as well as other activities that offered at those bases. It's not a handout. It's not a freebie. It is part of their retirement benefit package. A benefit package that was earned by spending 20 years or more of their lives defending this nation and the freedoms of its citizens. Now that Fort Monmouth is all but closed, all of the retirees and their dependents no longer have access to any of those privileges unless they are able to travel 50 miles to Ft. Dix.

By the way, all of those retirees you refuse to subsidize with your tax money? They also pay taxes.

Betsy

12:38 am on Saturday, August 13, 2011

Lynn as the daughter of a USN retired chief I thank you for your comments. My dad spent his life working for the Navy and yes you are right... I am proud of our military and our veterans who have served our country.. The benefits they receive ie commissary exchange and medical are well deserved considering there paycheck doesn't come close to what it should be for serving our country and giving us the chance to live our lives as freely as we do...

Reply

Leave a comment

 

The Long Branch-Eatontown Patch
Valentine's Shopping Guide

See the full guide!

Patch Picks